Nyheter
Time to short sugar, coffee and soybeans
ETF Securities Commodity Research – Time to short sugar, coffee and soybeans
Summery
- Sugar, coffee and soybeans have made spectacular returns this year, but much of their gains have been driven by currency movements, particularly the Brazilian Real.
- With record production of Arabica coffee and soybeans expected in 2016/17 and a narrowing deficit in sugar, the rally is likely to come under pressure.
- If the Brazilian Real remains stable, we expect fundamentals to prevail and the price of these sugar, coffee and soybeans to decline.
Brazilian Real drives rally
The El Niño weather pattern led to a failed monsoon in India and unseasonably wet weather in South America in 2015/16. However at the time of onset of the adverse weather, the price of sugar, coffee and soy made only muted moves. The sharp depreciation of the Brazilian Real weighed on their performance as stocks of these commodities could be sold in US Dollars, providing millers and farmers with improved margins. When the Brazilian Real started to appreciate we saw the price of the commodities make substantial returns. Year-to-date, sugar, coffee and soybeans have returned 35%, 19% and 25% respectively.
(Click to enlarge)
Weather patterns changing
The El Niño of 2015 was one of the most extreme on record by some measures, but the impacts of the weather phenomenon should be largely behind us now. The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration forecasts that the opposite weather phenomenon, La Niña, will emerge by the Northern Hemisphere autumn with a probability of 75%. La Niña involves a cooling of the Pacific Ocean (in a similar manner to El Niño warming the ocean), which changes trade winds and weather patterns from what is considered to be normal. Broadly speaking, areas that were excessively warm and dry in El Niño are likely to turn cool and wet in a La Niña. We assessed the likely impacts of La Niña emerging in autumn/winter (see Opportunity to short agriculture with La Niña) which highlights that the weather phenomenon is likely to be price negative for many crops with the exception of sugar. Cooler Southern Hemisphere temperatures are likely to reduce the heat damage that we have seen in the past crop. Sugar maybe an exception as cooler, wetter weather could reduce the sucrose content of cane in Brazil.
(Click to enlarge)
Record coffee production
After two consecutive years of production decline, coffee output is expected to rebound to an all-time high. Brazil, which produces approximately 45% of global Arabica supplies has seen favourable rain during the flowering of its coffee bushes, setting the scene for a healthy crop. Although the beginning of the harvest has been slowed by rain, current dry and warm weather should allow for field work to catch up. Brazilian output is expected to rise by close to 20% in the current 2016/17 crop.
Elsewhere, production in Honduras (7% of global production) is expected to make a recovery after the planting of ‘rust- resistant’ trees several years ago, which is helping to improve yields. The country has engaged in a renovation programme to protect its coffee from the rust-leaf fungus which has reduced production from Central America and Mexico for the past four years. Honduran production is likely to hit an all-time high of 6.1 mn bags (a 7% gain).
(Click to enlarge)
Narrowing sugar deficit
After 5 consecutive years of sugar surplus, 2015/16 was the first year of a deficit. The failed monsoon in India and Thailand has seen production in these two countries decline the most (the combined output of both countries is about 25% of global production). Production in Brazil (20% of global production) also declined, not because of a decline in cane growth, but because more cane was used for ethanol production.
The 2016/17 cane harvest in Brazil, which is about a quarter complete, is progressing 15% faster than last year’s harvest. With relatively low gasoline prices we don’t expect a large diversion to ethanol this year. Sugar production in Brazil is running 25% ahead of where it was last year and we expect a 7% increase in Brazilian sugar output in 2016/17.
(click to enlarge)
The Indian monsoon is currently approaching its northern limits and rainfall has been at the long-term average. In contrast to last year, resevoirs will likely be amply replenished. Indian sugar output is likely to rise as a result of more favourable conditions for its cane crop.
Sugar consumption is expected to rise by 1% globally, leaving the market in a production deficit despite the increase in supply. However, that supply deficit will narrow. While sugar stocks will continue to decline, they will remain above the long-term average of 31 million tonnes.
Soybeans head for record production
The Argentine soybean harvest in 2015/16, which is virtually complete, is expected to produce 8% less soybeans that the previous year as flooding in April and May spoiled the crop. Argentina provides approximately 20% of global production. Brazil (30% of global production) has seen its harvest remain close to the previous year’s levels. The 2016/17 year crop for Argentina and Brazil has not yet been planted.
The US 2015/16 crop was a record high. Although USDA projects a decline for 2016/17, we believe that their forecast remains overly conservative. By July 3rd 2016, 22% of the crop was blooming (8% ahead of last year) and 72% of crop was in good or excellent condition (10% better of last year). Moreover, planted acreage of soybean in the US has increased by 1%.
(click to enlarge)
Speculative positioning in soybean futures stand more than 1.5 standard deviations above the 5-year average, highlighting that investor optimism remains elevated. We believe that the investor optimism is a response to the disappointing Argentine crop of 2015/16. While the 2016/17 Southern Hemisphere crop is not yet in the ground, our analysis of La Niñas indicate that weather conditions could be quite favourable for the crop this year.
Downside risk to Real
While difficult to predict the path of a currency that has been so volatile in the past few years, we believe that the good news about relative political stability (after the impeachment of the President Dilma Rousseff) has been largely priced in. Economic conditions remain challenging for the country and therefore limit significant further appreciation. We believe that currency appreciation will no longer be a meaningful catalyst for price increases in sugar, soybean and coffee for the remainder of this year and the crops will trade on their own fundamentals. Rising production should therefore be price-negative.
Important Information
General
This communication has been issued and approved for the purpose of section 21 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 by ETF Securities (UK) Limited (“ETFS UK”) which is authorised and regulated by the United Kingdom Financial Conduct Authority (the “FCA”).
The information contained in this communication is for your general information only and is neither an offer for sale nor a solicitation of an offer to buy securities. This communication should not be used as the basis for any investment decision. Historical performance is not an indication of future performance and any investments may go down in value.
• $TRUMP & $MELANIA: The launch of both memecoins dominated headlines, with $TRUMP reaching a $73B fully diluted valuation. These launches are indicative of a late-stage bull market, often characterized by speculative exuberance.
• Solana Continues to Outperform: Solana reached an all-time high of $286, cementing its role as the leading blockchain for retail activity due to its high performance, low costs, and user-friendly ecosystem.
• Solana Remained Robust: Despite congestion and the rate of failed transactions rising by 20%, the network remained stable compared to prior years, avoiding outages even under unprecedented demand.
• Bitcoin Quietly Hits ATH: Ahead of the inauguration, Bitcoin surged to a new ATH just shy of $109K, largely under the radar amidst the memecoin frenzy.
• DeFi Momentum Builds: Trump’s World Liberty Fund continued its aggressive crypto accumulation, totaling $350M in cryptoasset holdings. This signals potential regulatory leniency for DeFi under the new administration.
• A New Crypto Era Dawns: With crypto-friendly cabinet nominees, initiatives such as the Bitcoin Strategic Reserve (BSR), a Presidential Crypto Council, an SEC-driven crypto task force, and moves to simplify regulations, the administration signals its intent to foster innovation while solidifying the U.S.’s leadership in the cryptoasset industry.
The crypto market surged in anticipation of Trump’s inauguration, especially following the launch of his official memecoin, $TRUMP, in the early hours of Saturday. The token’s fully diluted valuation soared to $73B, attracting around 850K holders and significantly boosting Trump’s net worth in Solana-based assets. Following this, First Lady Melania Trump introduced her own memecoin, $MELANIA, on Sunday. It briefly reached a market cap of approximately $2B before experiencing a 75% retracement, as seen below in Figure 1. The frenzy surrounding these tokens propelled Solana to reach an ATH of around $286 as investors rushed to buy the asset and participate in the ecosystem. However, it’s important to remember that this level of market exuberance typically signals the late stages of a bull market, warranting a more strategic approach from investors. Nevertheless, while vigilance is called for, it’s crucial to recognize that markets still have room for growth, particularly as asset prices often exhibit explosive upside movements in the latter stages of a bull market.
Figure 1: TRUMP & MELANIA Price Performance
Source: 21Shares, Dune
Despite $TRUMP’s questionable tokenomics and potential risks for inexperienced investors, its launch likely signals a shift toward a more crypto-friendly regulatory environment under the new administration. Further, the token’s controversial success highlights memecoins’ role as an effective tool for onboarding crypto newcomers. Unlike complex blockchain projects, memecoins offer a simpler entry point into the crypto world. They can serve as a ”trojan horse,” attracting retail investors with their accessibility and cultural appeal. This initial engagement can then potentially lead users to explore more sophisticated aspects of the crypto ecosystem, including decentralized finance (DeFi) applications and AI-based projects.
That said, their extreme volatility poses significant risks as inexperienced traders may suffer losses from the tokens’ wild price swings, potentially discouraging them from further engaging with crypto.
Despite the mixed short-term and long-term effects, last week’s events revealed a clear beneficiary: Solana. Thanks to its high performance and low costs, the network has now cemented its position as the go-to platform for retail activity. Despite intense usage over the weekend, it avoided typical outages seen in 2022 and 2023, demonstrating improved stability. While some applications, like Coinbase and Phantom, faced challenges with unprecedented demand, causing temporary transaction failures to increase by almost 20%, as seen below, Solana’s network remained robust compared to previous years. What’s worth remembering is that Solana’s resilience during this surge of activity, marked by zero outages, bodes well for its ambitious goal of becoming the ”NASDAQ on the Blockchain.”
Figure 2: Solana Failed Transaction Rate
Source: 21Shares, Dune
It’s worth noting that Solana’s robust performance during this activity surge, handling up to $45B in transactions on January 20 without any outages, demonstrates the network’s progress towards their North Star of becoming ”NASDAQ on the Blockchain.” This feat is particularly impressive when compared to Nasdaq’s average daily volume of $120B, underscoring Solana’s growing capacity to handle significant financial throughput.
As depicted below, even with a significant fee increase, Solana maintains cost-effectiveness, reinforcing its appeal to retail users. However, it’s crucial to look beyond its association with speculative activities. The network is now making significant inroads in diverse sectors, demonstrating its versatility and real-world utility. Notable examples include Decentralized Physical Infrastructure (DePIN) projects like Helium, Render, and HiveMapper; AI initiatives such as Griffain and Ai16z; and tokenization efforts supported by traditional financial institutions, including Franklin Templeton, Hamilton Lane’s SCOPE, and Ondo Finance. This broad spectrum of applications underscores Solana’s potential as a robust platform for innovation across multiple industries.
Figure 3: Solana Transaction Fees
Source: 21Shares, Dune
Similarly, Trump’s endorsed DeFi initiative, World Liberty Financial, has steadily expanded its cryptoasset holding over the recent weeks. In its latest round of acquisitions over the weekend, the project added $47M in ETH and WBTC and $4.7M each in Aave, LINK, TRX, and ENA to its portfolio. This takes the total amount of World Liberty’s holdings up to $350M worth of cryptoassets. It is worth noting that the yet-to-launch protocol is staking ETH with Lido, further echoing the idea that Trump is bullish on DeFi and that the industry will likely grow under his administration.
In this context, despite widespread anticipation, crypto was not mentioned in President Trump’s inaugural address or a leaked Republican policy document outlining national priorities. This omission contrasts with earlier speculation that crypto would become a central focus of the administration. However, it’s crucial to maintain a long-term perspective: Trump’s administration remains one of the most crypto-friendly globally, as evidenced by key pro-crypto appointments and proposed policies. In the following sections, we will explore these initiatives and their potential impact on the digital asset industry.
Bitcoin Strategic Reserve
While it may have gone under the radar, BTC also reached a new ATH, just shy of $109K, ahead of Inauguration Day. Relatedly, Trump’s administration has proposed creating a Bitcoin Strategic Reserve (BSR) to position Bitcoin as a critical financial and strategic asset, similar to gold reserves. The reserve would utilize approximately 80K Bitcoin seized by the U.S. Marshals, redirecting these assets into national holdings rather than auctioning them. Expanding the reserve to a rumored 1M BTC would require Congressional approval for market purchases or over-the-counter acquisitions, potentially funded by U.S. gold reserves.
Figure 4: Theoretical Bitcoin Strategic Reserve If 1M BTC Held Since 2016
Source: 21Shares, Coingecko
The BSR would classify Bitcoin as a strategic asset, held for at least 20 years and only sold to address U.S. debt. Advocates argue this could hedge against inflation, stabilize the dollar, and leverage Bitcoin’s appreciation to reduce national debt. Additionally, it could trigger a global race among nations to accumulate Bitcoin, driving its price higher and positioning the U.S. as a leader in the emerging digital economy. However, such a move would require significant regulatory changes and face challenges like volatility and opportunity costs.
Presidential Crypto Council
Trump’s administration plans to form a presidential crypto council of about 20 industry leaders, including CEOs and founders of major crypto companies. This advisory group would provide insights into the digital asset landscape and help shape innovation-friendly policies while addressing regulatory concerns. Rumored members include Michael Saylor (MicroStrategy), Brian Armstrong (Coinbase), Jeremy Allaire (Circle), Charles Hoskinson (Cardano/Ethereum), and Brad Garlinghouse (Ripple). The council aims to ensure crypto regulation reflects real-world challenges and opportunities, demonstrating the administration’s commitment to industry engagement and positioning the U.S. as a global blockchain leader.
SEC Repeal of SAB 121
A key rumored executive order from Trump’s administration involves repealing SAB 121, an SEC accounting rule requiring companies to treat client cryptoassets as balance sheet liabilities. This repeal would:
- Reduce operational risks for firms
- Encourage broader institutional participation
- Accelerate crypto service adoption in finance
- Signal a business-friendly regulatory approach
By easing regulatory friction, this move could enhance U.S. crypto firms’ competitiveness and position the country as a global leader in cryptoasset custody and management.
SEC and CFTC Joint Collaboration on Crypto Market Structure
Another key executive order reportedly under consideration by Trump’s administration involves directing the SEC and CFTC to collaborate on a crypto market structure bill, building on the foundation laid by the FIT21 framework. This initiative aims to establish a unified regulatory framework for digital assets, addressing long-standing jurisdictional ambiguities that have left cryptoassets caught between classifications as securities or commodities. The bill would create clear and consistent rules by fostering cooperation between these two agencies, reducing regulatory uncertainty, and fostering innovation.
Ending Operation Chokepoint 2.0: Restoring Banking Access for U.S. Crypto Companies
Trump’s administration plans to address the FDIC’s debanking of crypto companies and end ”Operation Chokepoint 2.0,” a controversial initiative that restricted banking access for the crypto industry with the likes of Kraken, Coinbase, Signature Bank, Paxos, and Binance.US all sharing a similar experience. The administration aims to restore fair treatment and financial access for crypto companies by instructing federal agencies to cease discriminatory practices. This move would provide stability, attract institutional players to the U.S. crypto market, and reaffirm the administration’s commitment to fostering a competitive financial environment.
SEC’s Shift in Stance Could Pave the Way for Expanded Crypto Spot ETPs
A revamped SEC under the new administration is set to redefine crypto regulations, legitimizing the industry and fostering innovation. Clear and fair rules would signal that the U.S. is open for business, attracting top talent and projects. This regulatory clarity is expected to unlock institutional capital as traditional finance gains the confidence to invest in digital assets with legal protections. The SEC’s progressive stance increases the likelihood of approving multiple spot crypto ETPs, enabling broader adoption and integration into traditional investment portfolios. This shift validates the crypto industry and positions the U.S. as a leader in financial innovation. Further, the newly established crypto-focused task force led by Commissioner Hester Pierce is designed to establish clear regulatory guidelines, practical registration paths, and sensible disclosure frameworks for crypto companies. Thus, this new body could help approve a broader range of ETPs.
Trump Cabinet Members
While Trump’s proposed appointees are yet to go through Senate approvals, here’s a quick overview of key pro-crypto members.
• Robert F. Kennedy Jr. (Secretary of Health and Human Services): A Bitcoin advocate who views it as the ”currency of freedom” and hedge against inflation, with most of his net worth invested in Bitcoin.
• David Sacks (Crypto and AI Czar): Early Bitcoin investor and backer of projects like Solana and dYdX, bringing deep expertise to blockchain innovation.
• Paul Atkins (Chair of the SEC): Former SEC commissioner with extensive experience helping crypto-native companies navigate regulatory compliance.
• JD Vance (Vice President): A Bitcoin supporter and venture capitalist with investments in blockchain startups and a crucial advocate for pro-crypto legislative initiatives.
• Elon Musk (Co-Head of D.O.G.E): A vocal supporter of blockchain innovation, holding Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Dogecoin, with Tesla’s $1.5B Bitcoin investment under his leadership.
• Vivek Ramaswamy (Co-Head of D.O.G.E): A vocal crypto advocate and co-founder of Strive Asset Management, Ramaswamy launched the Strive Bitcoin Bond ETF, proposed backing the U.S. dollar with Bitcoin, and champions clear regulations and wallet protections to drive innovation and financial freedom.
• Howard Lutnick (Secretary of Commerce): CEO of Cantor Fitzgerald, managing Tether’s U.S. treasury portfolio while acquiring a 5% stake, and holds personal Bitcoin investments worth hundreds of millions.
• Scott Bessent (Secretary of the Treasury): Founder of Key Square Group, Bessent advocates for balanced crypto regulations and has made sizable personal investments of $250K–$500K in Bitcoin ETPs.
For a deeper dive into their backgrounds and potential impact, check out our full breakdown on our latest blog.
All in all, while Trump did not address crypto in his inauguration speech or through executive orders, he has already begun appointing key figures supportive of the industry. Thus, he is starting to follow through with his promises. It seems he’s headed towards fostering a pro-crypto environment that provides a clearer path for companies to operate within the U.S.
Nevertheless, with the exuberant market activity we’ve seen in the last few days, it’s an opportune time for investors to stay mindful and ensure their positions remain aligned with their long-term objectives and risk tolerance.
What’s happening this week?
Research Newsletter
Each week the 21Shares Research team will publish our data-driven insights into the crypto asset world through this newsletter. Please direct any comments, questions, and words of feedback to research@21shares.com
Disclaimer
The information provided does not constitute a prospectus or other offering material and does not contain or constitute an offer to sell or a solicitation of any offer to buy securities in any jurisdiction. Some of the information published herein may contain forward-looking statements. Readers are cautioned that any such forward-looking statements are not guarantees of future performance and involve risks and uncertainties and that actual results may differ materially from those in the forward-looking statements as a result of various factors. The information contained herein may not be considered as economic, legal, tax or other advice and users are cautioned to base investment decisions or other decisions solely on the content hereof.
Trump 2.0: The Art of the Crypto Deal
Börshandlade produkter som ger exponering mot AAVE
UIW1 ETF ger exponering mot socialt ansvariga företag i Europa
Fidelity International-studie avslöjar att investerare förblir engagerade i ”E”, ”S” och ”G” men hinder kvarstår
I förra veckan gjorde SAVR årets första återbetalning av fondprovisioner
De mest eftersökta ETFerna i december 2024
Post-election rally cools at year end
De bästa ETFerna för värdeaktier
BlackRock slår rekord med lanseringen av bitcoin ETF
Hector McNeil kommenterar Trumps krav på Natos försvarsutgifter
-
Nyheter3 veckor sedanDe mest eftersökta ETFerna i december 2024
-
Nyheter2 veckor sedanPost-election rally cools at year end
-
Nyheter3 veckor sedanDe bästa ETFerna för värdeaktier
-
Nyheter3 veckor sedanBlackRock slår rekord med lanseringen av bitcoin ETF
-
Nyheter4 veckor sedanHector McNeil kommenterar Trumps krav på Natos försvarsutgifter
-
Nyheter3 veckor sedanBuffertstrategin på Nasdaq-100 med december 2024/2025 som ny målperiod
-
Nyheter4 veckor sedanValour PYTH SEK spårar priset på kryptovalutan PYTH
-
Nyheter2 veckor sedanHANetfs Tom Bailey om utsikterna för koppar och uran
