After recognizing in our recent newsletter, that this cycle is one characterized by upgrades, we want to dedicate this newsletter to an upgrade we’re especially curious about: Fantom’s migration to Sonic brewing this quarter.
Fantom, despite its longevity in the blockchain space, has faced challenges and setbacks since the previous market cycle. While key metrics such as active users and Total Value Locked (TVL) have declined, the network’s upcoming upgrade presents a promising opportunity for revitalization, which is what we’ll focus on here.
What is Fantom?
Launched in 2018, Fantom is a highly scalable platform that aimed to compete with Ethereum and other smart-contract rivals. In December 2019, Fantom’s Opera mainnet launched as a compatible blockchain with Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM). This means it’s interoperable with Ethereum and other EVM-compatible chains, such as Polygon, and Ethereum-scaling solutions like Arbitrum. With a mission to solve the blockchain trilemma, Fantom aims to create a secure and efficient global app store.
Figure 1 – Fantom in the Layers
Source: 21Shares
The Lachesis consensus mechanism is what makes Fantom’s blockchain fast and scalable. Its asynchronous and leaderless design enables validators to process transactions concurrently without waiting for prior block confirmations. This parallel processing architecture is what allows Fantom to achieve near-instant transaction finality.
With over 400 projects deployed on its network, Fantom’s adoption is mainly driven by its transaction throughput, 30 transactions per second (TPS), coupled with low fees, as shown below.
Figure 2 – Fantom’s Average Transaction Fee
Source: 21Shares, Fantom Explorer
Offering faster settlement than Ethereum (1-2 seconds) along with its EVM compatibility, meaning that developers can migrate their applications seamlessly from Ethereum, made Fantom grow to attract a total of over 179M unique addresses. At the peak of Fantom’s activity, it had almost $8B in TVL, as shown below.
Figure 3 – Fantom’s Total Value Locked
Source: 21Shares, DeFiLlama
However, Fantom’s TVL took a deep dive in April 2022 and has been sluggish ever since, suffering from several headwinds including the Terra Luna and FTX collapse in 2022 and the Multichain bridge hack in 2023.
On July 7, 2023, Multichain cross-chain bridge protocol experienced a significant security breach, resulting in unusually large and unauthorized withdrawals. The exploit led to losses exceeding $125M, with nearly $120M of that total coming from Multichain’s Fantom bridge. On its part, Fantom learned from its hard-learned lesson and has been working on a decentralized solution for that problem, which we’ll explore later in this report.
While the hack did not permanently cripple Fantom, the FTM token price fell by around 10-15% in the immediate aftermath, causing the TVL to drop by 30%, as users flocked away from the ecosystem.
Why is Fantom up by ~250% over the past year?
Figure 4 – Fantom’s Price Performance
Source: 21Shares, CoinGecko
The anticipation for the new Sonic upgrade has catalyzed investors to start preparing for the new iteration of the network, which will upend blockchain’s capabilities by offering improvements across performance, scalability, and efficiency.
So, What is Sonic?
In December 2023, Fantom launched Sonic Labs, an incubator aimed at empowering developers to create innovative dApps with enhanced performance, in preparation for the launch of the Sonic mainnet, slated for December 2024.
On the token side, $FTM will turn into $S following the mainnet deployment later in the year. Users will be able to swap both tokens at a rate of 1:1.
On a technological level, the rebranding aims to replace the old Opera blockchain with Sonic, which is focused on significantly increasing the network’s speed and settlement time, in addition to making it more decentralized. It also offers an attractive environment that tempts developers to migrate from competing ecosystems. While Opera will remain operational in the short term, Sonic’s compelling rewards and advanced features are poised to catalyze a mass migration, ultimately establishing it as Fantom’s new dominant network, which will then be known as Sonic.
Namely, it would accomplish these goals through the following areas:
Key Enhancements
• Transaction Speed: close to 2,000 transactions per second, almost a 100x improvement from its old benchmark.
• Transaction Finality: expected to occur in under 700 ms, rivaling high-throughput blockchains like Solana and catering to a broader segment of high-velocity applications.
• Storage Optimization: 65% reduction in node storage requirements, promoting network decentralization as it democratizes access to participating in the blockchain’s security by reducing the hardware requirements.
Improved Security and Developer Incentives
• Sonic Gateway: a decentralized bridge connecting Ethereum and Sonic, utilizing both networks’ validators to eliminate single points of failure. It also features a 14-day fail-safe mechanism, allowing users to recover assets on Ethereum if the gateway fails. The new L2 network will address previous security vulnerabilities that were associated with the previous multibridge hack.
• Gas Monetization: up to 90% of gas fees from qualifying dApps will be allocated back to their developers. This encourages applications with high usage to consider migrating from other ecosystems to generate more revenue via this gas-rebate program.
o For transactions related to applications that aren’t eligible under this model: 50% of fees will be burned with 45% distributed to validators, and 5% allocated to the ecosystem vault.
The new developer incentive program has already catalyzed a surge in application deployments on Fantom. Recent data indicates a significant uptick in the number of active developers on the platform, reaching new heights, as seen in Figure 5.
Figure 5 – Fantom Full Time Developers
Source: 21Shares, DeFiLlama
The amount of commits on the network, a concept referring to how many changes a particular app deployment has undergone, has also increased significantly since the announcement in May. In fact, the number of commits has reached a new high – a figure that is almost double the peak of 2021.
Figure 6 – Fantom Commits
Source: 21Shares, DeFiLlama
Both metrics are crucial, as developer activity often precedes wider adoption. As more developers build on a network, they create new use cases and applications, driving user growth and enhancing the blockchain’s overall utility and value proposition.
DeFi Ecosystem Boost
Introduction of a canonical USDC version. Fantom, in partnership with Circle and Wormhole, introduced USDC.e, a bridged version of the widely trusted USDC stablecoin. This strategic move enhances the ecosystem’s security by providing a reliable, trust-minimized bridging solution for the stablecoin. It also mitigates the depegging risks associated with lesser-known stables, addressing vulnerabilities exposed by incidents like the Multichain hack where compromised collateral led to a severe devaluation of bridged assets.
The integration of UDSC.e also lends credibility to the ecosystem, catalyzing a network effect. As high-quality protocols and assets deploy on the platform, it’s likely to attract other reputable DeFi projects, creating a virtuous cycle of ecosystem growth and adoption.
Since Sonic’s announcement in May, Fantom’s ecosystem has shown signs of revival. DEX trading volume has nearly doubled from its lows, despite only $7M in USDC.e being bridged so far. This uptick suggests growing interest, even as the wider DeFi ecosystem on Fantom has yet to emerge.
Figure 7 – Fantom DEX Volume
Source: 21Shares, Dune
The network’s financial landscape isn’t only receiving a boost via its enhanced stablecoin integration, but also through a series of innovative primitives proposed by Andre, the network’s co-founder, to help the blockchain stand out. His most remarkable proposal revolves around introducing credit scores:
• These are being developed on the back of a system that extracts, transforms, and integrates data across blockchains. So far, the foundation has processed over 54B transactions to create a wallet-scoring model without KYC or personal data.
• The goal is to tap into the $11T unsecured lending market, bringing products like payday and personal loans to the DeFi space, while supporting underbanked populations who lack access to conventional credit histories and help in decreasing interest rates.
However, Andre also has been sitting on multiple other primitives including:
• Advanced Oracle: an improved mechanism for robust validation of external data, enabling applications to seamlessly integrate diverse off-chain information sources while minimizing on-chain storage requirements and associated costs.
• Protection markets: an on-chain insurance framework that provides coverage for diverse claims. This system leverages collateralized vaults, strategically deploying assets into yield-generating strategies to create a robust and self-sustaining protection marketplace.
• Leveraged Spot Market: allowing users to deposit arbitrary margin assets to gain access to leveraged investments directly on-chain without relying on centralized parties – all whilst enjoying the trust-minimal aspect of smart-contracts for automatic risk management.
• FX-Swap: a DEX inspired by Curve Finance’s trading model which is optimized for low volatility correlated assets focused on tokenized fiat currencies.
Where is Fantom/Sonic going?
Sonic’s impending launch presents a compelling opportunity for growth, despite current market conditions. The platform’s strategic alignment with Ethereum through the Sonic Gateway, coupled with substantial financial resources ($500M in treasury) and innovative incentive programs, positions it for potential resurgence:
• Sonic Boom: A tiered airdrop program rewarding applications based on their ecosystem contributions. Exclusive protocols receive enhanced allocations.
• Sonic Gems: Users can earn points towards a 190,500,000 $S token airdrop, with 37.5% allocated to Sonic Gem holders.
This leads us to believe that Sonic will likely be able to attract a growing number of developers from across the Ethereum ecosystem. It will be driven by offering enhanced revenue opportunities while contributing to a superior network with high transaction throughput and user-friendly features. For instance, Sonic’s native account abstraction can help onboard new entrants to the blockchain ecosystem.
Finally, Fantom’s user base is currently exceeding the average of approximately 35K recorded over the past year, as depicted below. Thus, we expect the network to continue its growth trajectory over the next few months going into the upgrade.
Figure 8 – Fantom Active Wallet Addresses
Source: 21Shares, Dune
What should investors expect?
For investors looking to gain exposure to the longer tail of the cryptoasset ecosystem and capitalize on the latest developments, 21Shares offers the following Fantom ETP on the European market. This investment product provides a regulated way to capture growth opportunities within this rapidly evolving sector.
The potential transition timeline for 21Shares’ ETP is currently being discussed with 21Shares’ service providers. Investors in this ETP would not need to take any action and would be informed in line with the applicable exchange regulations via official notice prior to the change. We’ve prepared an FAQ for investors wishing to learn more about this upgrade and what it means for our product, so stay tuned.
Figure 9 – 21Shares Fantom ETP
Source: Bloomberg, Data as of September 30, 2024.
Avg. Daily Spread YTD: refers to the best daily average bid/ask spread this year across European exchanges.
Each week the 21Shares Research team will publish our data-driven insights into the crypto asset world through this newsletter. Please direct any comments, questions, and words of feedback to research@21shares.com
Disclaimer
The information provided does not constitute a prospectus or other offering material and does not contain or constitute an offer to sell or a solicitation of any offer to buy securities in any jurisdiction. Some of the information published herein may contain forward-looking statements. Readers are cautioned that any such forward-looking statements are not guarantees of future performance and involve risks and uncertainties and that actual results may differ materially from those in the forward-looking statements as a result of various factors. The information contained herein may not be considered as economic, legal, tax or other advice and users are cautioned to base investment decisions or other decisions solely on the content hereof.
The outcome of the US election last month continues to reverberate through the crypto markets. The Nasdaq Crypto IndexTM (NCITM) has risen over 57% since November 5, fueled by widespread optimism over the direction of digital asset policy in the US.
As I wrote in a previous note, crypto assets tend to follow a four-year cycle that includes a bull phase of roughly 12 months, followed by a year-long bear market, and then a two-year recovery period. In the previous two bull markets, altcoins (i.e., everything outside of BTC) have significantly outperformed the largest crypto asset.
I believe we’ve entered a bull market, reinforced by the macro environment and US election outcomes. But there’s another data point signaling a bull market—the outperformance of the NCITM relative to BTC.¹ In the last three months, the NCITM has had a higher return than BTC (78.0% vs. 76.5%) and since the election, the NCITM has outperformed BTC by 6.8%.
Crypto Asset Performance
So, which specific aspects of crypto are poised for outperformance this time around?
One key area to watch is smart contract projects, platforms that will allow users to transact not only information but value and property as well. We believe these platforms and applications will outperform BTC in the next 12-18 months as they compete for users and lay the groundwork for decentralized applications. On the back of the infrastructure developments we have seen in this area in the last few years, new applications are emerging across AI, gaming, and many other areas as tokenization continues to expand.
We also believe that new regulatory progress in 2025 will be more beneficial to these applications than to Bitcoin specifically, because Bitcoin already has regulatory clarity and a well-developed capital markets structure, with the growth of ETFs, options, and futures. In the US and Europe, this legislative and regulatory clarity that will benefit altcoins may include:
• Market structure legislation: Proposals like FIT21 will remove ambiguities regarding the commodity vs. security status of crypto assets, as well as create paths to registration that could boost adoption in the US.
• Stablecoin legislation / MiCA implementation: Both will drive the adoption of stablecoins in the US and Europe, expanding the stablecoin phenomenon beyond just emerging markets.
• Repeal of SAB121: When this obstacle is removed and US banks can hold crypto for their clients, banks and brokerages will increase their crypto trading and custody offerings, which will benefit altcoins the most.
• New ETF launches: With the new SEC chair, there are renewed hopes for additional ETF approvals, including indices and single assets like Solana and XRP. There’s still much uncertainty here, but new assets having ETFs as on-ramps is highly positive.
In addition to Bitcoin developing as an emerging digital store of wealth and smart contract platforms becoming a new way to exchange information, value, and property, there are three other altcoin use cases we believe will benefit in the coming year:
DeFi: Projects aimed at creating an internet-based financial system, running on smart contract platforms, will create a new global capital markets infrastructure for payments, with stablecoins and tokenized money market funds being the first important use cases.
Web3: A new iteration of the internet that will let us own our data and make the internet decentralized and more usable for things like AI agents and other innovations.
Digital Culture: An emerging digital-native generation will have more demand to own digital assets and collectibles, with gaming being a natural first application.
If we compare crypto to the internet, this industry is like the internet in the 1990s and Bitcoin could be compared to email—the only application most people hear about. But fast forward 20 years and while email is still very useful, it has not been the internet’s application that created the most societal value. We believe this could be true for how Bitcoin is currently viewed relative to crypto.
Benefits of diversification
Our team at Hashdex are firm believers that getting broad exposure to this market is necessary to capture the growth we believe we will experience in these other areas. Indices like the Nasdaq Crypto IndexTM (NCITM) can provide broader market exposure and, as crypto matures as an asset class, better risk-adjusted returns. Additionally, indices provide more significant optionality as investors don’t need to rely on an active manager to do this for them. The complexity and fast-evolving nature of crypto make it hard to pick individual winners and an index simplifies investing by offering a balanced, data-driven selection of assets that can align with modern portfolio theory principles.
This is why index ETFs have been at the core of our mission. Accessing crypto through these familiar structures allows investors to benefit from the growth of this asset class with minimal friction. For most investors, we most often recommend a very small allocation to crypto, from 1% to 5%. We strongly believe that a benchmark like the NCITM is an excellent way to “buy the market” and benefit from a strategic allocation into this promising asset class.
[1] The Nasdaq Crypto Index includes Bitcoin, Ethereum, Solana, Ripple, Cardano, Chainlink, Avalanche, Litecoin, Polygon, and Uniswap as of 9/30/24
Sedan i måndags har två ETFer från Xtrackers kunnat handlas på Xetra. Xtrackers MSCI Taiwan UCITS ETF (XTMT) följer utvecklingen av MSCI Taiwan 20/35 Custom Index. Investerare får därmed direkt tillgång till den taiwanesiska aktiemarknaden. Vikten för det största företaget är begränsad till 35 procent och de övriga företagens till 20 procent vardera. Det största företaget är för närvarande Taiwan Semiconductor. Totalt omfattar referensindexet 88 företag, som täcker cirka 85 procent av Taiwans börsvärde.
Xtrackers MSCI World ESG UCITS ETF (XZWD) följer utvecklingen av MSCI World Low Carbon SRI Selection Index. Indexet inkluderar stora och medelstora företag från utvecklade länder över hela världen. De måste ha bättre ESG-egenskaper och lägre koldioxidutsläpp jämfört med sina kamrater.
Båda fonderna är tillgängliga för investerare i den utdelande andelsklassen.
Produktutbudet i Deutsche Börses XTF-segment omfattar för närvarande totalt 2 318 ETFer. Med detta urval och en genomsnittlig månatlig handelsvolym på cirka 16 miljarder euro är Xetra den ledande handelsplatsen för ETFer i Europa.
Amundi S&P SmallCap 600 ESG UCITSETFDist (MWON ETF) med ISIN IE000XLJ2JQ9, försöker spåra S&P SmallCap 600 ESG+-index. S&P SmallCap 600 ESG+-index spårar amerikanska småbolagsaktier. Aktierna som ingår filtreras enligt ESG-kriterier (miljö, social och bolagsstyrning).
Den börshandlade fondens TER (total cost ratio) uppgår till 0,35 % p.a. Amundi S&P SmallCap 600 ESG UCITSETFDist är den enda ETF som följer S&P SmallCap 600 ESG+ index. ETFen replikerar det underliggande indexets prestanda genom fullständig replikering (köper alla indexbeståndsdelar). Utdelningarna i ETFen delas ut till investerarna (Minst årligen).
Amundi S&P SmallCap 600 ESG UCITSETFDisthar tillgångar på 117 miljoner euro under förvaltning. Denna ETF lanserades den 20 januari 2023 och har sin hemvist i Irland.
Investeringsmål
AMUNDI S&P SMALL CAP 600 ESG UCITSETFDISTförsöker replikera, så nära som möjligt, resultatet för S&P SmallCap 600 ESG+ Index oavsett om trenden stiger eller faller. Denna ETF erbjuder exponering mot värdepapper som uppfyller ESG-kriterier samtidigt som den bibehåller liknande branschgruppsvikter som S&P SmallCap 600 Index.
Det betyder att det går att handla andelar i denna ETF genom de flesta svenska banker och Internetmäklare, till exempel DEGIRO, Nordnet, Aktieinvest och Avanza.